Pizza Jeans

Great service, but I didn’t think the pizza was anything special. We ordered slices that were sitting under a heating lamp, they would’ve been much better fresh out of the oven I’m sure. Edit: went back this week and the pizza was reheated in the oven, which made it considerably better.

I've been wanting to try the pizza here at Pizza Jeans inside Ponce City Market for quite a while...AND today was that day! New York Cheese Pie, Please! Less than 20 minutes later, IT WAS ABOUT TO GO DOWN! Let me start with the very NYC pizza joint vibe they had going on. Loved everything about it! Very nostalgic playing 80's and 90's hits. Chill and relaxing times are here in spades! Let's get to the pizza review... Let it be known I am no Dave Portnoy from Barstool, but I have had more than my fair share of good, mediocre, and below average pizza . At 1st glance, it looked like I was in NYC at lunchtime. Solid overall appearance. Hot & Fresh. Good under carriage. Not too much flop. 1st bite, very good. Quality sauce. Great quality mozzarella cheese, with a good crunch. Crust had a great structure, great dough, and also resembled a similar crunch from the 1st bite. Overall I did very much enjoy this pizza. Score of 8.2

The pizza here was absolutely amazing hot, fresh, and full of flavor! What really made the experience even better was the exceptional customer service from Abner. He was so helpful, friendly, and made sure everything was perfect from start to finish. It’s rare to come across someone so genuinely kind and attentive. Great food and even better service definitely coming back!

Cute pizza joint in Ponce market. Pleasant service . Small seating area , decor was hip and cool. I ordered a pepperoni slice with dine hot honey to drizzle on top. The pizza was so good. I enjoyed my slice , I’m sure you will too!

Pizza Jeans is such a vibe! From the moment you walk in, the throwback aesthetic grabs your attention—the retro design mixed with the old-school music creates the perfect nostalgic atmosphere. It felt like stepping into a cool time capsule. The energy was great, and the whole place had a fun, laid-back feel. I absolutely loved the vintage touches and the playlist that made the experience even better. Definitely a spot I’d come back to—not just for the food, but for the whole vibe!

Amazing customer service and welcoming staff! Clean, chill, and the pizza was hot and fresh. I had pepperoni, but they had many options. Highly recommend as your go to pizza spot at Ponce or in the Atlanta area. :)

Five out of five. Incredible pizza! The staff was super friendly The layout was so cool. The pizza jeans in Ponce city gave me LA vibes with New York style (the best style) pizza. Music was good and loud, and their boxes are hilarious as they pay homage to a certain 1980s group of musicians that are a cult classic. Great job guys!

As we were walking past Pizza Jeans my I said to my bestfriend, “ooh! Their Pizza looks good!” And he looked at me and said, “AND IT IS!!” Now listen, he knows food like I know food so at that moment... I had to have someeeeeeeeee. Walking into the space it def gives off cute pizza bar vibes. The area is super clean, visually attractive and high energy. As I approached the cash register I was excited to see a menu. LoL! Don’t judge me, I was afraid I might have to read the writing on the wall. Haha!!! In any case, the hound lady was folding boxes to my left. She was super nice and welcomed me in. She told me to take my time and let her know when I was ready. Oh yeah, you know she got a tip. I love good service. Being in love with the 90’s I decided to get a Mall Slice of Cheese and a regular slice of Pepperoni. If you didn’t grow up in the 90’s, watch an episode of Saved By The Bell so you can understand the art, attraction, and hidden nostalgia of a mall slice. Placed my order, gave her my name and I was off to the side as they crafted my cheesy goodness. When my slices were ready, the guy called my name and as soon as I looked at the plates I was mesmerized. I saw cheese bubbling, plain white greasy plates and uneven crust. I was excitedddddddddddd. Now, as my eyes are first, I let the camera eat second because babeeeeeeee... if I didn’t, this review would have been all words. Ha. Though my bestfriend said the pizza was good, I’ll be adult enough to admit that he lied. This pizza is amazing. I’m talking, bake me up a whole pie and leave me to my foodie moment alone. A man and his pie. Lmbo. The crust was doughy but had a nice crisp to it. The under crust was this but not too thin, well baked and infused with the sauce and pizza perfectly. Don’t ask me which slice tasted better because I am unable to fully evaluate that question until I have 30 more slices of each. LoL. The cheese has its humble charm while the pepperoni had its texture variation and added robust pops of flavor, however, one thing for sure is that BOTH Slices were bite after bite of cheesy joy. If you’re in the area and ready for a pizza filled moment of pure happiness, head to Pizza Jeans and get you some food joy!!